Tuesday, November 13, 2012

By Kilian- Good Girl Gone Bad (In The Garden Of Good And Evil)

I dislike the first twenty minutes of By Kilian's Good Girl Gone Bad from the new In The Garden Of Good And Evil collection so much that it matters very little that it develops into a beachy coconuty tuberose that smells pretty good. As a matter of fact, I'm also not crazy about the dry-down that takes the form of berries and some synthetic wood. I guess this By Kilian and I were not meant to be.

The official note list (see below) reads very tempting. In reality, Good Girl Gone Bad starts with a pickle note and continues to smell quite vinegary on my skin. I'm pretty sure that it's me and not Kilian, but really, testing this fragrance was a challenge. Things start to improve once the cornichon is gone. Good Girl becomes equally sweet and salty and smells like a fantasy beach vacation. The tuberose is quite prominent when you sniff it on skin level, and the coconut is fun and adds a creamy/buttery facet.

The dry-down takes me back into fruity-floral territory. I'm not sure what's in there that makes Good Girl Gone Bad smell fake, plastic-like and full of berries. The fragrance is loud but not in a good way; If you told me this was the latest Victoria's Secret eau de stinky mall I'd have believed you. Right now I'm just glad to be done with this review so I don't have to test it ever again.

Notes: jasmine, osmanthus, rose, tuberose, narcissus, amber and cedar.

Photo: Gia Carangi by Scavullo for Vogue, July, 1980.
By Kilian- Good Girl Gone Bad from In The Garden Of Good And Evil collection ($245, 50ml EDP) is available from Luckyscent and select department stores. A sample set was sent to me via By Kilian's Facebook fan page.


  1. Thanks for this review. I almost bought a sample of this earlier today, you saved me a few bucks!

  2. I found it sour on my skin as well, and I never got past that.

  3. I nearly bought a bottle !!! I did say I would like a sample from Luckyscent but lets hope they give me somthing else!!!
    I hate - yes Hate - coconut scents !!! LOL

  4. I was sprayed with this at a store yesterday. I did not get past the top notes but those did not smell sour. My comment to the SA was "Good Girl's Eaten a Lolipop"

  5. LOL! I was wondering what that smell was - I've got it on my left arm and it's.....well.....bleachy-pickle is spot on!

    Glad to know it's not just me!



I love comments and appreciate the time you take to connect with me, but please do not insert links to your blog or store. Those will be deleted. The comment feature is not intended to provide an advertising venue for your blog or your commercial site.

Related Posts Widget